Dear colleagues [on behalf of Dave Martin and Paul Norman]
Understandably, only a few of us can
invest much time in following the plans for future censuses and you may
therefore be unaware of recent developments. If you are a user of small area
census data, please read on and act if you can - there is a real risk of losing
the small area census data that you currently take for granted.
ONS are
currently undertaking research on potential replacements for the conventional
census in 2021. Although that seems a very long way off, recommendations need to
go before parliament next year and the preparatory work is already well
advanced. Based on the series of roadshows run by ONS last autumn, they have not
received convincing high-value use cases for small area population attributes.
Arguments such as "they are used to target local services" are not sufficiently
robust to stand up to the inevitable financial scrutiny. A leading option is to
derive basic age/sex data from linked administrative records and to use social
survey data to obtain the types of population attributes that would previously
have been obtained from the census - (ethnicity, LLTI, tenure, car ownership,
employment, etc.) This would clearly not deliver small area data of the current
quality, if at all.
We are urgently appealing to the research community
to have your say: if no case is made, it seems entirely likely that ONS will not
be able to include generation of costly small area data as part of the
recommended option. If you can demonstrate high-value research (and ideally
high-valued impacts!) based on small area 2001 census data, please mail David Martin and Paul Norman (d.j.martin@soton.ac.uk, p.d.norman@leeds.ac.uk) - we
need to marshall further evidence by the end of February.
Ideally, we are
seeking identifiable research with an estimate of value and impact and/or an
indication of why it could not be done without high quality small area data. If
you can supply a paper or URL where further details could be pursued, better
still. NB This is about England and Wales, although Scotland and Northern
Ireland will be reviewing the same issues in due course.
If you want to
find out more about Beyond 2011, see http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/about-ons/what-we-do/programmes---projects/beyond-2011/index.html
Although there is not a formal consultation currently open, you can also mail
them at beyond2011@ons.gsi.gov.uk
With many thanks,
David Martin,
University of Southampton Email: D.J.Martin@soton.ac.uk
Paul Norman,
University of Leeds Email: P.D.Norman@leeds.ac.uk
Tuesday, 12 February 2013
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment